The Regrets of Cyrus Dodd
Bette Lee Crosby
Bent Line Publishing (2016)
Reviewed by David K. McDonnell for Reader Views (01/17)
“The Regrets of Cyrus Dodd” by Bette Lee Crosby chronicles a West Virginia farm family, from their days on the farm, to their life in a small Virginia town, to their later life as retired, empty-nesters. But, the book is far from a dry, fictional biography of ordinary people in an ordinary life, for the travails faced by the family and their reactions to them are like those of almost every reader. It is quite easy to empathize with the characters, especially since their story is so richly told.
The book’s opening paragraph is a wonderful lead-in to the story and perfectly illustrates Crosby’s style of writing:
“I have heard it said that a man who cries is spineless, a weakling not worthy of his salt, but this I can tell you: a man who has never shed a tear has not yet learned to love.”
Cyrus Dodd’s “regrets” are not so much regrets over wrong decisions made over the course of a lifetime, but unplanned and unwanted circumstances and events, which sometimes fortuitously occurred over that lifetime. Some of these are indeed tragic and thus worthy of both regret and sorrow. But others, as Cyrus said: “At long last I have come to realize the things I once counted as regrets were indeed blessings that I was too blind to see.”
Like in Crosby’s Wyattsville series of books, the story is generally told in the third person, with several short chapters told in the first person – by Cyrus and other lead characters. This puts the reader into the thoughts of the characters in a way that dialogue and description often cannot. One gets to know the characters in a deeply personal way.
The strong attachment of a farmer to his land, the consuming force of revenge and hate, the excruciating pain caused by the loss of a loved one, the quiet contentment of a strong marriage (and the overbearing bleakness of a bad one), and the power of friendship and family to overcome adversity, are each themes of the story. These themes are presented in a way that is almost, but not quite, melodramatic, or even sappy.
But, the power of the writing and the attachment to the characters keep the story within fictional reality and allows the themes to be emotionally felt by the reader. “The Regrets of Cyrus Dodd” by Bette Lee Crosby is, indeed, an engrossing story of ordinary people.