Dancer in the Bullpen

Chana Shinegba
Jaded Ibis Press, LLC (2024)
ISBN: 978-1938841279
Reviewed by Shelbie Thomas for Reader Views (08/2025)

Dancer in the Bullpen by Chana Shinegba is a riveting emotional story that blends autobiographical fiction with a thread of magical realism. The story follows Nina, a girl from a family of overachievers, from her earliest memories all the way to the birth of her own child.  Shinegba gives readers an unflinching look at how the impressions we absorb in childhood (both beautiful and painful) continue to echo into adulthood.

Nina grows up with two loving and successful parents.  The reality of divorce, remarriage, and frequent moves does, however, create instability that feeds her anxiety, depression, and constant fear of not measuring up.  Her parents’ expectations weigh heavily on her (especially her mother’s).  Their relationship is a source of love and comfort, and the strictness that leaves Nina terrified of ever letting her down – even feeling she might disappoint God. 

Dance becomes her escape; a passion she clings to from the age of four through high school graduation.  Along the way, she faces bullying, first loves and heartbreaks, addiction, faith struggles, infidelity (both hers and others), and the layered challenges of Black girlhood in the 80s and womanhood in the 90s. 

Through it all, Nina turns to her “magic.”  This seems to be a survival tool that blurs the line between imagination and reality.  Sometimes it’s her dog speaking to her, sometimes it’s a beloved relative returning in angelic form, sometimes it’s an uncanny ability to make bad things happen to people who hurt her.  This thread of magical realism seems to reflect the way people create meaning or cling to faith as a way of surviving hardship.

Dancer in the Bullpen is thoughtful because it shows the unfolding of Nina’s life stage by stage without rushing.  She’s a protagonist who feels real with her flaws and fears. Shinegba authentically captures Nina’s world as a Black girl growing up in America, making her story deeply personal and relatable.

One setback to such a strong work comes near the end of the story.  After such a patient unfolding of Nina’s life, her “happy ending” arrives too suddenly and leaves the final pages feeling rushed.  A little more time here would have given the resolution more weight. What stays with me most is Shinegba’s reminder that children soak up everything and anything they’re exposed to and carry those messages into adulthood.   One of the most prominent examples is Nina’s conviction, which we hear about every ten pages or so, that she must find a King to become a Queen.  This is a belief that she absorbed in childhood, long before she could even question why.

Chana Shinegba’s Dancer in the Bullpen is a brave and touching novel that will resonate with readers who like realistic and character-driven fiction.  Bonus points if they admire stories of resilience, identity, and survival.  With its mix of emotional honesty and a touch of magic, this work shows us how love and faith can carry us through the darkest times in our lives.

(Trigger warnings for addiction, domestic abuse, and infidelity.)