The Mystical Guatemalan Robes

Michael David Polansky
Independently Published (2023)
ISBN: 979-8989291502
Reviewed by Terri Stepek for Reader Views (09/2025)

Pick up a copy of Michael David Polansky’s The Mystical Guatemalan Robes: The Pilot and the Priest, and you’ll discover a story that is part historical fiction, part supernatural thriller, and nearly all action. As readers can infer from the full title, two characters will hold center stage, although several others will enter the fray. Many won’t survive. The pilot and the priest are about to turn the world upside down.

Let’s start with the priest, Fray Narvaez, in the 17th century. Perhaps he started his priesthood with the best of intentions. Certainly, his faith has never been questioned. He is passionate to the extreme. But his ways are strange; he frightens people—often staring at them, and the villagers near his monastery are convinced he is responsible for the heinous deaths of several children. He is. In fact, as we meet the priest, the villagers are about to storm the monastery to kill Narvaez as he is being given his new commission: to join Hernando Cortes in his quest to the New World. If only the villagers had succeeded.

…something cold touched Pedro’s heart and made his entire body shudder. The eyes that looked up at him were not the eyes of a cleric, but those of a madman. Pg. 7

The author turns readers from that chaos to the peace of a pilot doing what he loves best. John Pulitzer is a Vietnam vet working for AireWest Airlines. He loves his family, truly. But he really loves flying for AireWest, the airline that has outpaced all others for years. He’s a good guy with a lot of bad baggage, including PTSD that manifests in a form of obsessive-compulsive behavior that could be called dogged determination.

Readers would now be wondering why a 20th-century pilot will soon find himself confronting that 17th-century priest. It’s a fair question. But I can’t explain it as neatly as the author can:

The fervor and intensity of Fray Narvaez’s dreams had been tapped by an ancient civilization masquerading as God and settled deep in the jungles of Guatemala—a civilization that had destroyed the Mayan culture to preserve the secrecy of their existence.  Pg 13

You read that right. Aliens who wiped out the Mayans when they became too inquisitive have accepted this pedophile priest and granted him special powers, perhaps even immortality. He’s perfect for the job. But John Pulitzer begins to make connections and soon (unknowingly) finds himself on the trail of the hideously evil priest (who kills for fun) and his alien benefactors (who kill to protect their secrets).

By the time we as readers are beginning to have a clue, the plot races off like a thoroughbred at the Kentucky Derby. It’s time to hold on and turn pages as fast as you can, because things are going to get crazy. Speaking of crazy, as if it’s not enough that a heinous 350-year-old priest is terrorizing people, there are a couple of people within the ranks of AireWest that are going to complicate matters even further. There’s a narcissistic exec with a secret agenda who’s been failing his way up to the top. There’s also a pilot who has no business being in a cockpit. Pulitzer is the man to get him removed, but he’s busy being chased by aliens and a morally corrupt ancient priest. Pulitzer’s life is… complicated.

The premise behind The Mystical Guatemalan Robes is good; fascinating, even. The historical elements are impactful in many ways, and the storylines in the ranks of AireWest are likewise intriguing. Polansky does a great job of weaving two tales seemingly at odds into one high-flying adventure. However, readers should be aware that many of the character arcs will remain unresolved at the end of this novel, which also features a fairly titanic cliffhanger. It’s fair to assume that Mr. Polansky has more that he wants to share regarding the priest, the pilot, and the aliens who would happily wipe humankind off the Earth.

As for me, I would have liked more character development with Captain Pulitzer and especially concerning Chester (the serially bad pilot). As fascinating as Chester’s storyline is, there are times when it doesn’t make sense to focus on his chaos when there is already plenty to go around. One can only assume it’s because we’ll see more of Chester in a coming episode.

I would like to compare The Mystical Guatemalan Robes by Michael David Polansky to other books that readers might know. But it seems this novel stands on its own. Fans of action/adventure books will enjoy going from ancient Europe to the Aztec empire with Cortez’s Conquistadors, and into the late 20th century. Readers who enjoy supernatural thrillers will find great enjoyment in the hidden aliens’ storyline, and pitted battles with the FBI vs. The Pedophile Priest et al. (kind of sounds like a bad Fight Night title). I would call this a fairly light read, but the subjects of child kidnapping, molestation, and murder require trigger warnings instead. Polansky, however, does not portray these scenes in a graphic manner. If you’re looking for an absolutely unique action, adventure, or thriller read, look no further than The Mystical Guatemalan Robes.