The Notorious Murder of Ellar Day

Marcy S. Wood
Steinmetz Press (2026)
ISBN: 979-8995638605
Reviewed by Paul Knobloch for Reader Views (09/2026)

Marcy S. Wood’s The Notorious Murder of Ellar Day is an ambitious work of historical fiction that combines romance, murder, racial violence, and the rough social politics of an 1880s Colorado mining town. Based on historical events, the novel begins with its ending: Ellar Day tells us from beyond the grave that she was murdered. Wood therefore makes the mystery not whether Ellar will die, but how a young woman with intelligence and considerable determination becomes trapped by circumstances that steadily eliminate her choices.

At seventeen, Ellar is already a mother and trapped in a disastrous marriage to Charles Woodcock. Discovering the extent of her husband’s infidelity finally pushes her toward divorce, but freedom in 1880s Ouray proves relative. Ellar can leave a husband, but she cannot easily escape the expectations surrounding her sex, class, family, and religion. Wood is particularly effective at showing how those forces become internalized. Ellar repeatedly makes decisions she believes are practical or moral, only to discover that the available choices have already been severely restricted.

Ellar’s relationship with Joseph Dixon gives this conflict its greatest emotional force. Joe, a Black cook and former Buffalo Soldier, understands immediately what Ellar initially does not: an interracial relationship places them in radically unequal danger. Ellar risks reputation and family rejection; Joe risks his life. Their romance develops slowly, allowing friendship, attraction, and mutual respect to precede their sexual relationship. Joe’s memories of military service also complicate him considerably. He carries guilt over violence committed against Indigenous people while serving a country that grants him only conditional citizenship and safety. Wood’s larger point is the all-encompassing power of ideology and institutions: even a formerly enslaved man can be absorbed into a system that requires him to participate in the oppression of others.

Wood surrounds this central relationship with a convincing portrait of a community governed by race, gender, money, and reputation. Prostitutes are denied medical treatment; women have little reliable control over pregnancy; Black residents navigate rules that white citizens barely notice. Minnie Percy, Ellar’s closest friend, is particularly memorable. Her experiences as a sex worker could easily have been treated as colorful Western background, but Wood instead uses Minnie to expose another form of social confinement. Even the novel’s railroad struggle matters beyond historical atmosphere. The competition between Ouray and the proposed town of Chipeta reveals men attempting to manufacture fortunes, communities, reputations, and ultimately history itself.

Mark Atkins embodies the darkest version of that impulse. Initially appearing to offer Ellar the respectable future Joe cannot safely provide, Mark gradually reveals racism, possessiveness, and a terrifying ability to interpret his desires as righteousness. His religious language becomes increasingly disturbing because he can transform jealousy and violence into evidence of his own virtue. The baptism scene, in which he nearly drowns Joe while ostensibly saving his soul, brings these contradictions together brilliantly.

The final chapters are consequently tragic rather than merely shocking. Ellar’s pregnancy destroys the precarious arrangement she has constructed, while racism provides a ready-made explanation for the violence that follows. The truth matters less than the story those left behind are able to tell, and here The Notorious Murder of Ellar Day finds its greatest strength. In her author’s notes, Wood carefully distinguishes documented events from invention and acknowledges that the circumstances surrounding Ellar and Joe’s deaths cannot now be recovered with certainty. Rather than claiming to solve the crime, the novel asks a more interesting question: whose voices survive long enough to become history?

The supernatural framing finally acquires its purpose here. Ellar narrates because the living world failed to preserve her voice. Her reunion with Joe after death provides emotional resolution, while Raymond’s visit to his mother’s unmarked grave decades later supplies something quieter and more affecting. Even Ellar’s gravestone has disappeared. What remains is memory, fragmentary evidence, and the possibility of telling the story differently, making The Notorious Murder of Ellar Day both a tragic love story and a thoughtful examination of who possesses the power to determine how tragedy will be remembered.


At a Glance: Historical fiction based on an 1880s Colorado murder, blending tragic romance, racial conflict, and supernatural narration. A young woman’s interracial relationship unfolds within a mining community shaped by prejudice, gender restrictions, religious pressure, and competing versions of truth.

Best for Readers Who Enjoy: historical fiction, Western historical fiction, interracial romance, tragic love stories, historical murder mysteries, books about racial injustice, women defying social conventions, mining town settings, fiction based on true events, supernatural historical fiction