To ensure consistency across our scoring process, we have refined the 1–5 evaluation scale for each question. Please use the guide below to align your scores with the intended standards:

5 – Excellent: Highly polished, deeply effective, and delivers exceptional quality. Minimal flaws.
4 – Good: Good quality overall, well-done but not quite exceptional. Not without flaws but only a handful.
3 – Borderline: Uneven execution with more than a handful of flaws or weaknesses that reduce the book’s quality and overall impact.
2 – Poor: Serious problems undermine quality.
1 – Ineffective: Fundamentally flawed; fails to deliver.